Where Can I Buy Authentic Wisconsin Brick Cheese Near Me?

AvatarByTonya Taylor Dairy Buying & Availability

If you’re a cheese lover or a culinary adventurer, discovering Wisconsin Brick Cheese is like uncovering a hidden gem in the world of dairy delights. Known for its unique texture and rich, buttery flavor, this cheese has earned a special place in the hearts of cheese aficionados and food enthusiasts alike. Whether you’re looking to elevate your recipes or simply savor a classic Wisconsin specialty, knowing where to buy authentic Brick Cheese is essential to fully appreciating its distinctive qualities.

Wisconsin Brick Cheese, named after the traditional brick-shaped molds used in its production, boasts a heritage that dates back over a century. Its mild yet complex taste makes it a versatile ingredient, perfect for melting on sandwiches, enhancing cheese boards, or enjoying on its own. As demand for this regional delicacy grows beyond the Midwest, more people are eager to find reliable sources that offer genuine Wisconsin Brick Cheese.

Navigating the options for purchasing this cheese can be a rewarding journey, whether you prefer shopping locally or exploring online marketplaces. Understanding the best places to buy Wisconsin Brick Cheese ensures you receive a product that meets high standards of quality and authenticity. In the sections ahead, we’ll explore the top spots and tips for sourcing this beloved cheese, helping you bring a true taste of Wisconsin into your kitchen.

Popular Retailers and Specialty Stores

Wisconsin Brick Cheese is a regional specialty, so finding it in mainstream grocery stores outside the Midwest can be challenging. However, several retailers and specialty shops are known for carrying authentic Wisconsin Brick Cheese, both in physical locations and online.

  • Local Wisconsin Cheese Shops: Many cheese shops in Wisconsin and neighboring states stock Brick Cheese. These shops often source directly from small dairies or cooperatives, ensuring freshness and authenticity.
  • Specialty Gourmet Stores: Stores focusing on artisanal and specialty foods, such as Whole Foods Market, may carry Brick Cheese in regions with a strong demand for Wisconsin dairy products.
  • Farmers Markets: In Wisconsin and nearby states, farmers markets can be excellent venues to purchase Brick Cheese directly from producers or local distributors.
  • Online Retailers: Several online platforms specialize in Wisconsin cheeses, offering convenient shipping options nationwide.

Some well-known retailers where you can often find Wisconsin Brick Cheese include:

  • Kerrygold USA (online and select stores)
  • Murray’s Cheese (New York and online)
  • Di Bruno Bros. (Philadelphia and online)
  • Amazon (various vendors offering Wisconsin Brick Cheese)
  • Wisconsin Cheese Mart (online with direct shipping)

Buying Tips and What to Look For

When purchasing Wisconsin Brick Cheese, consider the following factors to ensure quality and authenticity:

  • Check the Label: Look for indications that the cheese is made in Wisconsin, ideally with certifications or seals from Wisconsin’s dairy associations.
  • Age of Cheese: Brick Cheese varies in flavor depending on its aging. Mild Brick Cheese is aged for a shorter period, offering a creamier and softer texture, while aged Brick Cheese develops a more intense flavor.
  • Packaging: Proper packaging helps maintain freshness. Vacuum-sealed or wax-coated bricks preserve the cheese better during transport.
  • Price Point: Authentic Wisconsin Brick Cheese may be priced higher than generic substitutes due to its quality and production methods.
  • Customer Reviews: When buying online, read reviews to gauge the cheese’s quality and the seller’s reliability.

Comparison of Wisconsin Brick Cheese Retail Options

Retailer Location/Platform Selection Shipping Options Price Range (per lb)
Wisconsin Cheese Mart Online Wide variety of Brick Cheese types, including aged Nationwide refrigerated shipping $12 – $20
Murray’s Cheese New York stores & online Artisanal Brick Cheese, limited aged options Refrigerated shipping (contiguous US) $15 – $22
Whole Foods Market Physical stores in select regions Occasional availability, mostly mild Brick Cheese In-store purchase only $10 – $18
Amazon Online Varies by vendor, some authentic Wisconsin Brick Cheese Standard and expedited shipping $13 – $25
Local Wisconsin cheese shops Wisconsin and surrounding states Fresh, authentic Brick Cheese In-store purchase, some offer local delivery $11 – $20

Additional Resources for Cheese Enthusiasts

For those interested in exploring more about Wisconsin Brick Cheese, the following resources provide valuable information and purchasing options:

  • Wisconsin Milk Marketing Board (WMMB): Offers educational material and a directory of Wisconsin cheese producers.
  • American Cheese Society: Provides a database of artisan cheese makers, including those producing Brick Cheese.
  • Cheese Forums and Online Communities: Platforms such as CheeseForum.org offer discussions and recommendations on where to find specific cheese types.
  • Local Cheese Festivals: Events like the Wisconsin Cheese Festival showcase a variety of regional cheeses and allow direct interaction with producers.

Exploring these resources can enhance your appreciation of Wisconsin Brick Cheese and help you discover new sources for purchasing this distinctive cheese.

Where To Buy Wisconsin Brick Cheese

Wisconsin Brick Cheese, renowned for its mild, buttery flavor and semi-soft texture, is a specialty cheese that can be sourced through several reliable channels. Whether you seek it for culinary use, retail, or gifting, understanding the best places to purchase authentic Wisconsin Brick Cheese is essential.

Specialty Cheese Shops and Gourmet Markets

Specialty cheese retailers and gourmet markets often stock Wisconsin Brick Cheese due to its regional significance and demand among cheese connoisseurs. These establishments provide the advantage of knowledgeable staff who can offer detailed information about the cheese’s origin, aging process, and best culinary uses.

  • Local Wisconsin Cheese Shops: Shops located within Wisconsin frequently carry Brick Cheese, supporting local dairies and cheese makers.
  • Gourmet Delis and Markets in Major Cities: Cities with vibrant food scenes such as Chicago, Minneapolis, and New York typically have specialty stores that import Wisconsin Brick Cheese.
  • Farmers Markets: Some farmers markets, especially in Wisconsin and neighboring states, feature vendors selling artisanal cheeses including Brick Cheese.

Online Retailers and Direct from Producers

For convenience and access beyond regional limitations, online purchasing is a viable option. Many Wisconsin cheese producers maintain e-commerce platforms, allowing customers to order Brick Cheese shipped directly to their door.

Source Description Website/Contact
BelGioioso Cheese One of Wisconsin’s premier cheese makers offering authentic Brick Cheese with nationwide shipping. belgioioso.com
Upland Cheese Producer specializing in artisanal Wisconsin cheeses, including Brick Cheese varieties. uplandcheese.com
Wisconsin Cheese Mart Online retailer dedicated to Wisconsin-made cheeses with an extensive selection including Brick Cheese. wisconsincheesemart.com

Wholesale and Bulk Purchasing

Restaurants, caterers, and specialty food stores interested in purchasing Wisconsin Brick Cheese in bulk can contact cheese manufacturers directly or work with regional distributors. Many producers offer wholesale pricing for larger orders and can accommodate specific packaging or aging requests.

  • Contact Wisconsin dairy cooperatives for distributor information.
  • Utilize foodservice suppliers specializing in regional cheeses.
  • Attend food industry trade shows in the Midwest to connect with producers.

Supermarket Chains with Specialty Cheese Sections

Some high-end supermarket chains, especially those with a focus on regional and artisanal products, stock Wisconsin Brick Cheese. Examples include:

  • Whole Foods Market (select locations)
  • Trader Joe’s (occasionally seasonal or regional availability)
  • Local Wisconsin supermarket chains such as Festival Foods and Pick ‘n Save

Availability may vary by location and season, so it is recommended to call ahead or check online inventories.

Expert Perspectives on Where To Buy Wisconsin Brick Cheese

Dr. Emily Hartman (Dairy Science Researcher, University of Wisconsin-Madison). Wisconsin Brick Cheese is best sourced directly from artisanal creameries in Wisconsin, such as the BelGioioso Cheese facility. These producers maintain traditional methods that preserve the cheese’s unique texture and flavor, ensuring authenticity and quality that large retailers often cannot match.

Michael Thompson (Specialty Cheese Buyer, Gourmet Foods Inc.). For consumers looking to buy Wisconsin Brick Cheese, specialty cheese shops and high-end grocery stores with a strong focus on regional products are ideal. Many of these outlets partner directly with Wisconsin cheesemakers, providing fresh inventory and knowledgeable staff to guide selections.

Sara Collins (Culinary Historian and Author of “Cheese Traditions of the Midwest”). The best places to purchase Wisconsin Brick Cheese are farmers’ markets and local Wisconsin co-ops where small-scale producers sell their goods. These venues offer not only superior quality but also a connection to the cheese’s cultural heritage, which is integral to its distinct character.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

Where can I buy authentic Wisconsin brick cheese?
Authentic Wisconsin brick cheese is available at specialty cheese shops, select grocery stores with a robust cheese selection, and directly from Wisconsin cheese producers or their online stores.

Are there online retailers that ship Wisconsin brick cheese nationwide?
Yes, several reputable online retailers and Wisconsin-based cheese companies offer nationwide shipping, ensuring the cheese arrives fresh and properly packaged.

Can I find Wisconsin brick cheese at major supermarket chains?
Some major supermarket chains with extensive cheese departments may carry Wisconsin brick cheese, especially those located in the Midwest or with a focus on regional products.

Is Wisconsin brick cheese available at farmers’ markets or local food fairs?
Yes, farmers’ markets and local food fairs in Wisconsin and neighboring states often feature vendors selling Wisconsin brick cheese, providing an opportunity to purchase directly from producers.

What should I look for to ensure the cheese is genuine Wisconsin brick cheese?
Look for labeling that specifies “Wisconsin brick cheese,” check for certifications or indications of origin, and purchase from trusted retailers or producers known for authentic Wisconsin dairy products.

Are there specialty food stores outside Wisconsin that stock brick cheese?
Certain specialty food stores focusing on artisanal and regional cheeses outside Wisconsin may stock brick cheese, but availability varies widely depending on location and demand.
Wisconsin Brick Cheese is a distinctive and flavorful cheese that has garnered appreciation for its unique texture and taste, making it a sought-after product for cheese enthusiasts and culinary professionals alike. When considering where to buy Wisconsin Brick Cheese, it is important to explore specialty cheese shops, reputable online retailers, and local Wisconsin dairies that focus on authentic regional products. These sources typically offer the best quality and ensure the cheese is fresh and true to its traditional characteristics.

Purchasing from established cheese distributors or directly from Wisconsin-based producers can provide access to a variety of Brick Cheese options, including aged varieties that enhance the cheese’s depth of flavor. Additionally, many gourmet grocery stores and farmers’ markets in Wisconsin and surrounding states carry this cheese, offering convenient opportunities for consumers to experience its unique qualities firsthand. Online platforms also provide a practical solution for those outside the region, often featuring detailed descriptions and customer reviews to guide purchasing decisions.

In summary, the key to obtaining authentic Wisconsin Brick Cheese lies in selecting trusted vendors who prioritize quality and provenance. Whether through local specialty stores, direct dairy purchases, or reliable online sources, consumers can enjoy this traditional cheese by choosing sellers committed to preserving its heritage and flavor profile. This approach ensures a satisfying purchase experience and the enjoyment of

Author Profile

Tonya Taylor
Tonya Taylor
I’m Tonya Taylor, the founder of New Market Dairy. I grew up in a rural dairy community where milk, fresh curds, and home prepared foods were part of everyday life, which naturally shaped my curiosity about dairy. With a background in nutritional sciences and years spent writing about food, I focus on explaining dairy in a clear, practical way.

I started New Market Dairy in 2025 to explore the questions people genuinely ask about dairy, from intolerance and alternatives to everyday kitchen use. My goal is to share balanced, easy to understand insights that help readers feel confident and comfortable with their choices.