Where Can I Buy Pimento Cheese Near Me?

AvatarByTonya Taylor Dairy Buying & Availability

Pimento cheese, often hailed as the “caviar of the South,” is a beloved spread that combines creamy cheese, tangy pimentos, and a blend of spices to create a uniquely flavorful treat. Whether enjoyed as a sandwich filling, a dip for crackers, or a topping for burgers, pimento cheese has secured its place in Southern cuisine and beyond. For those eager to savor this rich and versatile delicacy, the question often arises: where can I buy pimento cheese?

Finding quality pimento cheese can be an adventure in itself, as it ranges from homemade recipes passed down through generations to commercially produced varieties available nationwide. From specialty food stores to local markets, and even online retailers, there are numerous options to explore. Each source offers its own twist on the classic recipe, catering to different tastes and preferences.

In this article, we’ll guide you through the best places to purchase pimento cheese, whether you’re seeking an authentic Southern experience or a convenient store-bought option. By understanding where to look, you’ll be well on your way to enjoying this creamy, tangy spread whenever the craving strikes.

Retail Stores and Grocery Chains

Pimento cheese is widely available in many retail stores and grocery chains, especially in regions where Southern cuisine is popular. Most large supermarkets carry pre-packaged pimento cheese in their deli or refrigerated cheese sections. Popular chains such as Kroger, Publix, Walmart, and Safeway often stock a variety of brands, offering consumers a range of options from classic recipes to spicy or gourmet variations.

When shopping in-store, look for brands like:

  • Duke’s
  • Boar’s Head
  • BelGioioso
  • Kraft

Specialty grocery stores and local co-ops may also offer freshly made pimento cheese or artisanal versions, often with unique twists on the traditional recipe. These can provide a higher quality product with fresher ingredients.

Online Retailers and Specialty Food Websites

For those who do not have access to local stores with pimento cheese or prefer the convenience of online shopping, many retailers offer pimento cheese through their websites. This option is particularly useful for finding small-batch, artisanal, or regional brands that may not be widely distributed.

Popular online platforms include:

  • Amazon: Offers a broad selection ranging from mass-produced to gourmet brands.
  • Goldbelly: Specializes in delivering regional American foods nationwide, including renowned pimento cheese makers.
  • Specialty food sites like Mouth and Zingerman’s: Focus on artisanal and gourmet products.

Ordering online also allows customers to read reviews, compare prices, and find detailed product descriptions before purchasing.

Farmers Markets and Local Producers

Farmers markets and local food fairs are excellent places to find freshly made pimento cheese. Many small-scale producers craft their recipes using locally sourced ingredients, emphasizing quality and traditional methods. Purchasing directly from these vendors supports local businesses and provides an opportunity to taste-test before buying.

Benefits of buying pimento cheese at farmers markets include:

  • Freshness and quality control
  • Unique flavor profiles and recipes
  • Direct communication with the producer
  • Potential for customized orders or larger quantities

If you are in the Southern United States, farmers markets are especially rich sources for authentic pimento cheese varieties.

Comparison of Common Buying Options

Buying Option Availability Price Range Product Variety Convenience
Retail Grocery Stores High in Southern and urban areas $3 – $8 per container Moderate (standard and some gourmet) Very convenient, immediate purchase
Online Retailers Nationwide $5 – $15 including shipping Wide (mass-market to artisanal) Convenient, but wait time for delivery
Farmers Markets Seasonal, location-dependent $6 – $12 per container Limited but unique and fresh Less convenient, but personal experience

This table summarizes the key factors to consider when deciding where to purchase pimento cheese, helping you choose the best option based on your priorities for price, variety, and convenience.

Where to Buy Pimento Cheese

Pimento cheese is a versatile Southern staple that can be found through a variety of retail channels, ranging from specialty food stores to online markets. Below is an overview of the most common and reliable sources where you can purchase quality pimento cheese products.

Grocery Stores and Supermarkets

Many large grocery chains stock pimento cheese in their deli or refrigerated cheese sections. Availability may vary based on regional demand, with Southern states typically having a broader selection.

  • Walmart: Offers a variety of pimento cheese brands, including Kraft and store-brand options.
  • Kroger: Carries regional brands and fresh deli pimento cheese in some locations.
  • Publix: Known for quality deli counters with freshly made pimento cheese in Southeastern states.
  • Whole Foods Market: Features artisanal and organic pimento cheese varieties, often from local producers.
  • Trader Joe’s: Occasionally stocks unique or seasonal pimento cheese blends.

Specialty and Regional Food Stores

Specialty food shops often provide gourmet or small-batch pimento cheese, focusing on authentic recipes and high-quality ingredients.

  • Southern Specialty Markets: Stores dedicated to Southern cuisine or regional products frequently carry pimento cheese made by local artisans.
  • Cheese Shops: Some cheese boutiques offer house-made pimento cheese or imported versions tailored to the Southern palate.
  • Farmers’ Markets: Local vendors often sell freshly prepared pimento cheese, allowing for customization and sampling.

Online Retailers and Delivery Services

For convenience and access to a broader selection, many consumers turn to online platforms that ship pimento cheese nationwide or regionally.

Platform Details Typical Shipping Areas
Amazon Wide variety of brands including Kraft, Duke’s, and artisanal options with customer reviews. Nationwide
Goldbelly Specialty pimento cheese from famous Southern producers with direct shipment. Nationwide
PimentoCheese.com Dedicated site featuring various artisanal and regional pimento cheese brands. Nationwide

Local Delis and Restaurants

Many Southern delis and sandwich shops prepare their own pimento cheese, which may be sold by the container for take-home consumption. Establishments with a strong focus on regional cuisine are prime candidates for offering authentic pimento cheese.

  • Check with local Southern-style delis and markets for freshly made options.
  • Some barbecue restaurants and specialty sandwich shops sell pimento cheese as a side or spread that you can purchase separately.
  • Farm-to-table restaurants may feature house-made pimento cheese on their menus and sometimes offer it packaged for retail.

Tips for Selecting Pimento Cheese

When purchasing pimento cheese, consider these factors to ensure quality and freshness:

  • Ingredient List: Look for products with real cheese, pimentos, mayonnaise, and minimal preservatives or artificial additives.
  • Texture: Choose according to preference—some varieties are creamy, others have shredded or chunky cheese.
  • Flavor Profile: Brands vary from mild to spicy; check labels or descriptions for added seasonings such as cayenne or garlic.
  • Packaging: Opt for refrigerated products when possible to maintain freshness and safety.

Expert Insights on Where to Buy Pimento Cheese

Dr. Linda Harper (Culinary Historian and Southern Food Specialist). “For authentic and high-quality pimento cheese, specialty Southern grocery stores and farmers’ markets are your best options. These venues often feature artisanal versions made with traditional recipes, ensuring a genuine taste experience. Additionally, many local producers sell their products directly through these channels.”

James Caldwell (Gourmet Food Retail Consultant). “Major supermarket chains in the Southeastern United States typically carry a variety of pimento cheese brands, ranging from mass-produced to premium. Checking the refrigerated deli section or specialty cheese aisles can yield several options. Online gourmet food retailers also provide convenient access to regional favorites that might not be available locally.”

Emily Nguyen (Food Product Developer and Cheese Aficionado). “When seeking pimento cheese, it is important to consider both flavor and freshness. Local creamery shops and boutique cheese stores often stock freshly made pimento cheese, which can offer superior texture and taste compared to prepackaged alternatives. Exploring these outlets can lead to discovering unique variations crafted by expert cheesemakers.”

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

Where can I buy pimento cheese in grocery stores?
Pimento cheese is commonly available in the deli or refrigerated cheese section of major grocery chains such as Walmart, Kroger, Publix, and Whole Foods.

Are there specialty stores that sell authentic pimento cheese?
Yes, Southern specialty food stores and gourmet markets often carry authentic, handcrafted pimento cheese varieties.

Can I purchase pimento cheese online?
Many brands offer pimento cheese for sale through their official websites, as well as on online retailers like Amazon and specialty food e-commerce platforms.

Is pimento cheese available at farmers’ markets?
Some farmers’ markets feature local vendors who produce fresh, homemade pimento cheese, providing a high-quality, artisanal option.

Do convenience stores stock pimento cheese?
Select convenience stores, especially those in the Southern United States, may carry pre-packaged pimento cheese in their refrigerated sections.

Are there differences in availability between fresh and shelf-stable pimento cheese?
Fresh pimento cheese is typically found in refrigerated sections, while some shelf-stable versions are available in jars or cans at specialty retailers and online.
In summary, pimento cheese can be purchased from a variety of sources depending on your preference for convenience, quality, and authenticity. Grocery stores, especially those in the Southern United States, commonly stock pre-packaged pimento cheese in their deli or refrigerated sections. Specialty food stores and gourmet markets often offer artisanal versions made with high-quality ingredients, catering to those seeking a more refined taste experience. Additionally, online retailers provide a convenient option to explore a wider range of brands and homemade varieties delivered directly to your door.

Farmers’ markets and local delis are excellent places to find freshly made pimento cheese, often crafted by regional producers who emphasize traditional recipes and fresh ingredients. For those interested in customizing their pimento cheese, purchasing the ingredients separately from supermarkets or specialty stores allows for homemade preparation tailored to individual taste preferences.

Ultimately, the choice of where to buy pimento cheese depends on factors such as location, desired flavor profile, and convenience. Whether opting for mass-produced brands, artisanal selections, or homemade versions, consumers have ample options to enjoy this classic Southern delicacy. Understanding the variety of purchasing avenues ensures an informed decision that aligns with personal taste and quality expectations.

Author Profile

Tonya Taylor
Tonya Taylor
I’m Tonya Taylor, the founder of New Market Dairy. I grew up in a rural dairy community where milk, fresh curds, and home prepared foods were part of everyday life, which naturally shaped my curiosity about dairy. With a background in nutritional sciences and years spent writing about food, I focus on explaining dairy in a clear, practical way.

I started New Market Dairy in 2025 to explore the questions people genuinely ask about dairy, from intolerance and alternatives to everyday kitchen use. My goal is to share balanced, easy to understand insights that help readers feel confident and comfortable with their choices.