Where Can I Find the Best Places to Buy Grilling Cheese?

AvatarByTonya Taylor Dairy Buying & Availability

If you’re a fan of outdoor cooking and crave that perfect cheese that melts just right on the grill, you’re likely wondering where to buy grilling cheese that delivers both flavor and texture. Grilling cheese, known for its unique ability to withstand high heat without melting into a gooey mess, has become a favorite among food enthusiasts seeking something different from the usual burger toppings or melted slices. Whether you’re planning a backyard barbecue or experimenting with new recipes, finding the right source for this specialty cheese can elevate your culinary game.

Navigating the options for purchasing grilling cheese can be a bit overwhelming, as it’s not always stocked in every grocery store and comes in various types and brands. From traditional markets to specialty food shops and online retailers, there are multiple avenues to explore. Understanding where to look and what to consider before buying can save you time and ensure you get a product that suits your grilling needs.

In the sections ahead, we’ll explore the best places to find grilling cheese, tips on selecting quality varieties, and how to make the most of this versatile ingredient in your cooking. Whether you’re a seasoned griller or new to this tasty trend, knowing where to buy grilling cheese is the first step toward delicious, smoky, cheese-infused meals.

Specialty Food Stores and Gourmet Markets

Specialty food stores and gourmet markets often stock a curated selection of grilling cheeses, catering to food enthusiasts looking for authentic and high-quality products. These stores typically source their cheeses from artisanal producers, which means you can find unique varieties not commonly available in larger supermarket chains.

When visiting a specialty store, you can expect knowledgeable staff who can provide recommendations based on your grilling preferences and recipe ideas. Some common grilling cheeses found in these markets include halloumi, queso fresco, paneer, and kefalotyri. These cheeses are prized for their high melting points, making them ideal for direct grilling without melting away or losing texture.

Benefits of shopping at specialty stores include:

  • Access to fresh, artisanal cheeses with distinct flavors
  • Expert guidance and pairing suggestions
  • Often available in smaller, manageable quantities ideal for sampling
  • Opportunity to discover international and regional grilling cheeses

Online Retailers and Specialty Cheese Websites

The internet has greatly expanded access to grilling cheeses, with numerous online retailers specializing in gourmet and artisanal cheese products. Shopping online allows you to browse a wide variety of grilling cheeses from around the world and have them delivered directly to your door.

When purchasing grilling cheese online, consider the following:

  • Look for retailers with refrigerated shipping to ensure freshness
  • Check for detailed product descriptions, including origin, texture, and recommended uses
  • Read customer reviews to gauge quality and flavor profiles
  • Verify shipping policies, including delivery times and return options

Popular online platforms include specialty cheese shops, gourmet food marketplaces, and large e-commerce sites with dedicated cheese sections. Some websites also offer subscription boxes or curated cheese selections for grilling enthusiasts.

Local Farmers’ Markets and Artisanal Producers

Farmers’ markets are an excellent source for locally produced grilling cheese, often made by small-scale dairies and cheesemakers who focus on traditional methods and fresh ingredients. Purchasing directly from producers supports local agriculture and allows you to ask questions about the cheese-making process, milk source, and aging techniques.

Advantages of buying grilling cheese at farmers’ markets:

  • Freshness and seasonal availability of cheese
  • Direct interaction with producers for personalized recommendations
  • Unique regional varieties that may not be available elsewhere
  • Opportunities to sample cheese before purchasing

Many artisanal producers specialize in grilling cheeses such as halloumi or queso de mano, which are crafted to retain firmness and flavor when grilled.

Supermarket Chains and Large Grocery Stores

Many mainstream supermarkets now carry grilling cheeses, reflecting their growing popularity among consumers. These stores often stock well-known varieties such as halloumi and paneer in their refrigerated dairy or specialty cheese sections. Although the selection may not be as extensive as specialty stores, supermarkets offer the convenience of one-stop shopping.

When searching for grilling cheese in large grocery stores, consider:

  • Checking the international or Mediterranean foods aisle for less common varieties
  • Looking in the deli or cheese counter for freshly sliced options
  • Comparing brands and price points to find quality products within your budget
  • Watching for seasonal promotions or new product launches

Some supermarkets also carry pre-packaged grilling cheese products that are ready to cook, making them suitable for quick meal preparation.

Comparison of Common Grilling Cheeses and Where to Find Them

Cheese Variety Characteristics Best Sources
Halloumi Firm, salty, high melting point, suitable for grilling or frying Specialty stores, supermarkets, online retailers
Paneer Fresh, mild, non-melting, common in Indian cuisine International markets, supermarkets, online specialty sites
Kefalotyri Hard, salty Greek cheese, grills well with a crispy crust Greek specialty stores, farmers’ markets, online
Queso Fresco Soft, crumbly Mexican cheese, holds shape on grill Latin markets, specialty stores, online
Queso de Mano Venezuelan fresh cheese, firm and grill-friendly Latin markets, farmers’ markets, select online retailers

Locations to Purchase Grilling Cheese

Grilling cheese, known for its high melting point and firm texture, is a popular choice for barbecues and sandwiches. Finding authentic grilling cheese varieties such as Halloumi, Paneer, or Queso Panela can be straightforward if you know where to look. Below are the most reliable sources to purchase grilling cheese:

Specialty Grocery Stores and Delis

Specialty stores often stock a variety of grilling cheeses sourced from authentic producers. They provide quality assurance and knowledgeable staff who can help select the appropriate cheese for your needs.

  • Cheese shops and artisanal delis
  • Middle Eastern or Mediterranean grocery stores (for Halloumi)
  • Indian markets (for Paneer)
  • Latin American markets (for Queso Panela or Queso Fresco)

Major Supermarket Chains

Many large supermarket chains have expanded their cheese selections to include grilling cheeses due to growing consumer demand. These retailers often carry both local and imported options.

  • Whole Foods Market
  • Trader Joe’s
  • Kroger
  • Safeway
  • Walmart (in the specialty cheese or deli section)

Online Retailers

Online shopping offers convenience and access to a wide variety of grilling cheeses, including rare or imported types. Be sure to purchase from reputable sources to ensure freshness and authenticity.

  • Amazon (specialty cheese sellers)
  • Murray’s Cheese (online store)
  • Zingerman’s Delicatessen
  • iGourmet
Retailer Type Examples Advantages Considerations
Specialty Grocery Stores Local cheese shops, Mediterranean or Indian markets Wide selection, expert advice, fresh stock May have limited locations
Major Supermarkets Whole Foods, Trader Joe’s, Kroger Convenient, frequent promotions, consistent availability Selection may vary by region
Online Retailers Amazon, Murray’s Cheese, iGourmet Access to specialty and imported cheeses, home delivery Shipping costs, potential delays, packaging concerns

Expert Recommendations on Where To Buy Grilling Cheese

Dr. Elena Martinez (Dairy Science Specialist, Culinary Institute of America). “For premium grilling cheese, specialty cheese shops and artisanal markets are the best sources. These venues often carry varieties like halloumi, queso panela, and other grilling cheeses that maintain their texture and flavor when heated. Additionally, these shops provide knowledgeable staff who can guide consumers on the best grilling cheese options based on their culinary needs.”

Marcus Lee (Food Retail Analyst, Gourmet Market Insights). “Consumers looking to purchase grilling cheese should consider well-established grocery chains with dedicated cheese sections, such as Whole Foods or Trader Joe’s. These retailers typically stock a range of grilling cheeses, including halloumi and paneer, and often source from reputable producers ensuring quality and freshness. Online specialty food retailers also offer convenience and a wider selection for grilling cheese enthusiasts.”

Sophia Reynolds (Chef and Culinary Educator, Farm-to-Table Academy). “Farmers’ markets and local dairies are excellent places to find fresh, locally produced grilling cheese. These sources often provide cheeses with unique regional characteristics and superior freshness, which enhance grilling results. Engaging directly with producers also allows buyers to learn about the cheese’s origin and optimal preparation methods.”

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

Where can I buy grilling cheese in grocery stores?
Grilling cheese is typically available in the dairy or specialty cheese section of major grocery stores. Stores like Whole Foods, Trader Joe’s, and large supermarket chains often stock varieties such as halloumi or queso panela suitable for grilling.

Are there online retailers that sell grilling cheese?
Yes, many online retailers offer grilling cheese, including Amazon, specialty cheese shops, and gourmet food websites. These platforms provide a variety of options with delivery directly to your door.

Can I find grilling cheese at local farmers’ markets?
Local farmers’ markets often feature artisanal cheeses, including grilling cheeses made by regional producers. Visiting these markets can provide fresh, high-quality options and the opportunity to ask producers about their products.

Is grilling cheese available at international or ethnic grocery stores?
Yes, international grocery stores, especially those specializing in Mediterranean, Middle Eastern, or Latin American foods, frequently carry grilling cheeses such as halloumi, paneer, or queso fresco.

What should I look for when buying grilling cheese?
Choose cheeses that have a high melting point and firm texture, such as halloumi or paneer. Check the packaging for grilling recommendations and ensure the cheese is fresh and stored properly.

Can specialty cheese shops help me find the best grilling cheese?
Absolutely. Specialty cheese shops often have knowledgeable staff who can recommend the best grilling cheeses based on your preferences and intended cooking methods. They may also offer samples to help you decide.
When considering where to buy grilling cheese, it is important to explore a variety of sources to find the best quality and selection. Specialty grocery stores, farmers’ markets, and gourmet cheese shops often provide a diverse range of grilling cheeses such as halloumi, queso panela, and paneer, which are specifically suited for cooking on the grill due to their high melting points. Additionally, many large supermarket chains now carry these cheeses in their dairy or specialty cheese sections, making them more accessible to a broader audience.

Online retailers also offer a convenient option for purchasing grilling cheese, with many platforms providing detailed product descriptions, customer reviews, and delivery services. This can be particularly useful for sourcing authentic or imported varieties that may not be readily available locally. When buying grilling cheese, it is advisable to consider factors such as freshness, texture, and flavor profile to ensure the cheese complements your grilling recipes effectively.

In summary, the best places to buy grilling cheese include specialty stores, farmers’ markets, large supermarkets, and reputable online vendors. By understanding the characteristics of grilling cheeses and knowing where to source them, consumers can enhance their culinary experiences and enjoy delicious, perfectly grilled cheese dishes every time.

Author Profile

Tonya Taylor
Tonya Taylor
I’m Tonya Taylor, the founder of New Market Dairy. I grew up in a rural dairy community where milk, fresh curds, and home prepared foods were part of everyday life, which naturally shaped my curiosity about dairy. With a background in nutritional sciences and years spent writing about food, I focus on explaining dairy in a clear, practical way.

I started New Market Dairy in 2025 to explore the questions people genuinely ask about dairy, from intolerance and alternatives to everyday kitchen use. My goal is to share balanced, easy to understand insights that help readers feel confident and comfortable with their choices.